Hear no evil, See no evil, Speak no evil

Let's talk about important issues

Governance & Power  ›  Regulation  ›  Public Bodies & Fiscal Oversight  ›  EHCR - EU - An independent judicial body.

EHCR - EU - An independent judicial body.

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) reports to the Council of Europe, an international organization founded in 1949 with the aim of promoting human rights, democracy, and the rule of law in Europe. Here"s how the reporting structure works:

1. Council of Europe

  • Role: The ECHR is a judicial body established by the Council of Europe. The Court"s primary role is to ensure that member states of the Council of Europe adhere to the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the European Convention on Human Rights.
  • Structure: The Council of Europe comprises 46 member states (as of 2024), and its main decision-making bodies are the Committee of Ministers (composed of the foreign ministers of all member states or their representatives) and the Parliamentary Assembly (composed of members from the national parliaments of member states).

2. Committee of Ministers

  • Function: The Committee of Ministers is responsible for overseeing the execution of the ECHR"s judgments. After the Court issues a judgment, it is the Committee of Ministers that monitors whether the member state in question complies with the ruling.
  • Reporting: While the ECHR is independent in its judicial functions, it indirectly "reports" to the Committee of Ministers in the sense that the latter ensures that states follow through on the Court"s decisions.

3. Execution of Judgments

  • Monitoring Compliance: When the ECHR delivers a judgment, the affected state is obliged to comply. The Committee of Ministers supervises the implementation of the Court"s judgments, ensuring that states take necessary steps to rectify the violations identified, which may include compensation to victims, changes in domestic laws, or other corrective actions.

4. Independence of the ECHR

  • Judicial Independence: Although the ECHR is part of the Council of Europe, it operates independently in its judicial capacity. The judges of the ECHR are elected by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe and serve in their personal capacity, meaning they do not represent their countries.

Summary:

The ECHR operates under the auspices of the Council of Europe, with its judgments supervised by the Committee of Ministers. However, the Court itself remains an independent judicial body, and its primary "reporting" function is to ensure that member states uphold the European Convention on Human Rights.